Two pouches, two different carry styles
The Rattray's Black Knight and the Scotch Plaid tartan pouch both hold pipe tobacco, but they solve different problems. The Black Knight is a small stand-up leather pouch with a rubber-lined interior, sized for roughly 25g. The Scotch Plaid is a double-pocket roll-up with a wipe-clean vinyl lining, sized for 50g. Choosing between them comes down to how much tobacco you carry, how you like to open and close a pouch, and whether leather or a wipe-clean fabric suits your routine.
Rattray's Black Knight: small, stand-up, leather
- Rattray's Black Knight Leather Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Small Stand Up 2: Capacity of tobacco in grams: 25g approx. This is a compact pouch for a short outing or a single day's smoking rather than a week's supply.

Rattray's Black Knight Leather Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Small Stand Up 2 - Rattray's Black Knight Leather Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Small Stand Up 2: Length when closed: 110mm; height when closed: 75mm; width: 70mm These dimensions describe a small, boxy pouch that stands upright on a table and takes little room in a bag.
- Rattray's Black Knight Leather Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Small Stand Up 2: Made from soft but robust black calf leather, with an odourless natural rubber interior Leather gives it a traditional look; the rubber lining is intended to protect tobacco freshness without tainting the flavour.
- Rattray's Black Knight Leather Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Small Stand Up 2: Fastening: 2 magnetic studs; accessories pockets: no; pipe storage: no It is a tobacco-only pouch. If you want to carry a pipe or tamper in the same case, this is not that design.
Scotch Plaid: double-pocket roll-up for 50g
- Scotch Plaid (Tartan) Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Green: Capacity: 50g Twice the approximate capacity of the Black Knight, so it suits longer trips or smokers who go through more tobacco.

Scotch Plaid (Tartan) Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Green - Scotch Plaid (Tartan) Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Green: Length: 150mm; height: 85mm; depth: 10mm It is longer and flatter than the Black Knight, which affects how it sits in a pocket or bag.
- Scotch Plaid (Tartan) Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Green: Scottish plaid, double pocket tri-fold roll-up design with a wipe-clean vinyl lining The roll-up format opens flat and the vinyl lining can be wiped clean, which is practical for everyday use.
- Scotch Plaid (Tartan) Pipe Tobacco Pouch - Green: Please note pattern and colors may vary from product shown The tartan you receive may differ from the product photo, so buy it for the format rather than an exact pattern match.
Capacity and size: how much tobacco do you actually carry?
The Black Knight holds approximately 25g; the Scotch Plaid holds 50g. That difference matters most if you smoke several bowls a day or pack for a weekend. The Black Knight's closed dimensions of 110mm by 75mm by 70mm make it a small, upright box. The Scotch Plaid measures 150mm by 85mm by 10mm, so it is longer and much flatter. Neither figure tells you whether the pouch will fit a specific jacket pocket or travel bag, so check those measurements against your own gear.
- Short trips and small quantities: The Black Knight's 25g capacity suits an afternoon out or a day's smoking without carrying excess tobacco.
- Longer trips and larger quantities: The Scotch Plaid's 50g capacity gives you roughly twice the tobacco in one pouch.
- Pocket or bag fit: The Black Knight is compact and stands upright; the Scotch Plaid is longer and flatter. Compare the supplied dimensions with your own pocket or bag rather than assuming a fit.
Leather versus wipe-clean vinyl: what changes day to day
The Black Knight uses soft black calf leather outside and an odourless natural rubber lining inside. The Scotch Plaid uses a tartan outer with a wipe-clean vinyl lining. Both linings are described as protecting the tobacco, but the materials behave differently in use. Leather develops a patina and feels more traditional; vinyl is easier to wipe clean after a spill. The supplied information does not include care instructions for either pouch, so follow the retailer's guidance rather than assuming a cleaning method.
- Look and feel: The Black Knight is understated black leather with a chrome Triskel logo; the Scotch Plaid is a tartan pattern that may vary from the photo.
- Cleaning: The Scotch Plaid's vinyl lining is described as wipe-clean. The Black Knight's rubber lining is described as odourless and freshness-preserving, but no cleaning method is supplied.
- Fastening: The Black Knight closes with two magnetic studs. The Scotch Plaid is a tri-fold roll-up; the supplied record does not describe its fastening.
Price and value: what the catalog shows
At the time of writing, the catalog lists the Rattray's Black Knight at USD 18.84 (comparison price USD 27.70) and the Scotch Plaid at USD 3.28 (comparison price USD 4.75). The Scotch Plaid is considerably cheaper and holds more tobacco, while the Black Knight costs more for its leather construction and smaller capacity. Neither price tells you which will last longer or suit your smoking habits better; that depends on how often you carry tobacco and what you value in a pouch.
What the supplied information does not settle
The catalog does not state whether either pouch is airtight, water-resistant, or suitable for long-term storage. It also does not give care instructions, warranty details, or confirmation that the Black Knight's rubber lining is replaceable. The Scotch Plaid's pattern and colours may vary from the product shown. Use the supplied dimensions and capacities to judge fit, and treat any unlisted feature as unconfirmed rather than assuming it is present or absent.



