Pipe Lighter Buying Guide: Peterson Marble Grey vs Xikar Resource II
By Smoke-King Tobacconist | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Buying Guides
Compare the Peterson Marble Grey and Xikar Resource II pipe lighters on flame, feel, fuel, and features to pick the right one for your briar.
Quick answer
Choose the Peterson Marble Grey if you want a sturdy, wind-resistant angled twin flame and a classic Old Boy-inspired feel; choose the Xikar Resource II if you prefer a soft angled flame, a built-in tamper, and a fuel gauge that takes the guesswork out of refilling.
Flame type and wind resistance
The Peterson uses an angled twin-hole nozzle, which is designed for easy lighting and wind resistance. That makes it a practical choice for outdoor smoking or breezy conditions. The Xikar Resource II has an angled soft flame, which many pipe smokers prefer for a gentler light that is less likely to scorch the tobacco. Neither lighter is described as a torch, so both are intended for traditional pipe lighting rather than heavy-duty wind fighting.
Feel, size, and hand fit
The Peterson is built in a beefier case with a larger cap, and the catalog lists it at 6.5 cm tall, 3 cm wide, and 66 g. That extra heft can feel reassuring in the hand, but it is noticeably heavier than many pocket lighters. The Xikar Resource II is described as fitting comfortably in the hand, though no dimensions or weight are supplied, so you cannot compare exact size from the catalog alone. If hand feel is your top priority, try to handle both or read the return policy before ordering.
Fuel management and everyday use
The Xikar Resource II has a large fuel tank and a side gauge so you can check the gas level before you head out. Its flame adjustment is at the bottom, and the electronic piezo action means no flints are needed. The Peterson does not list a fuel gauge or piezo ignition in the supplied facts, so you should not assume either feature. It does carry a 2-year guarantee, which is a concrete after-sales benefit. The Xikar's guarantee is not stated in the catalog, so ask the store if that matters to you.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Wind resistance vs flame softness: The Peterson's twin-hole nozzle is built for wind resistance, while the Xikar's soft flame is gentler on tobacco. If you often smoke outdoors, lean Peterson; if you smoke indoors and want a mild light, lean Xikar. Match the flame to where you usually smoke.
- Heft vs pocketability: The Peterson weighs 66 g and measures 6.5 x 3 cm, so it feels substantial but takes up more pocket space. The Xikar's dimensions are not listed, so compare in person if pocket carry matters. Check the Peterson's listed size against your pocket or pouch.
- Fuel visibility vs guarantee: The Xikar gives you a fuel gauge and piezo ignition with no flints, while the Peterson offers a 2-year guarantee but no stated gauge. Decide whether you value knowing your fuel level more than a stated warranty. Ask about the Xikar's warranty before you buy if that tips the decision.
Product facts at a glance
- Peterson of Dublin Pipe Lighter - Marble Grey: Angled twin-hole nozzle for easy lighting and wind resistance. Helps you light evenly in breezy conditions without torching the tobacco.
Peterson of Dublin Pipe Lighter - Marble Grey - Xikar Resource II Pipe Lighter - Black & Burlwood: Large fuel tank with a side gas gauge and pull-out tamper. Fewer refills and a built-in tamper mean less gear to carry and more consistent packing.
Xikar Resource II Pipe Lighter - Black & Burlwood
Which pipe lighter suits you?
Best for
- Pipe smokers who often light outdoors and want wind resistance
- Buyers who prefer a heavier, Old Boy-style lighter with a stated 2-year guarantee
Not for
- Smokers who want a visible fuel gauge and built-in tamper
- Buyers who prioritize a soft flame over wind resistance
