Quick answer
Choose Ashford Virginia Tubing Tobacco if you want a low-cost, high-volume Virginia leaf for everyday tubing. Choose Brookfield American Blend Tubing Tobacco if you prefer a mild-to-medium creamy American blend and want the convenience of a larger 200g tub.
Leaf style and the flavor trade-off
Ashford Virginia is a pure Virginia tobacco that has been expanded through a rapid heating and dry-ice cooling process, which visibly increases its volume. That expansion means you get more fill per gram, but the flavor tends to be lighter and faster-burning than a denser blend. Brookfield American Blend is a traditional American-style mixture described as mild to medium with a creamy smoke. It is not expanded, so it packs more tobacco mass per gram and delivers a fuller, more rounded taste. The trade-off is straightforward: Ashford gives you more cigarette volume for your money, while Brookfield gives you a richer flavor profile per gram.
Pack size and how you tube
Ashford comes in a 50g can, which suits tubers who make small batches or want to test a blend before committing to a larger quantity. Brookfield comes in a 200g tub, which reduces the frequency of reordering and is practical if you tube regularly. Both are designed for cigarette tubing machines, but Brookfield is also suitable for hand rolling if you prefer that method. If you use a tubing machine, the expanded nature of Ashford means you may need to adjust your pack pressure slightly to avoid over-compressing the fill. Brookfield's denser blend behaves more predictably in most machines, though you should always follow your machine's instructions.
Cost per gram and upfront outlay
The catalog prices are USD 28.06 for the 50g Ashford can and USD 136.80 for the 200g Brookfield tub. On a per-gram basis, Ashford works out to about USD 0.56 per gram, while Brookfield is about USD 0.68 per gram. However, Ashford's expanded volume means you get more cigarettes per gram, so the effective cost per cigarette may be even lower. The catch is that Ashford requires more frequent purchases, while Brookfield ties up more money upfront but lasts longer. Neither product listing includes optional size or strength variants, so you are choosing between these two fixed formats.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Flavor intensity vs volume: Ashford's expanded Virginia leaf gives you more cigarette volume per gram but a lighter taste. Brookfield's denser American blend delivers a fuller, creamy flavor with less volume per gram. If flavor is your priority, Brookfield is the better fit; if you want more cigarettes from each gram, choose Ashford.
- Upfront cost vs long-term value: Ashford costs USD 28.06 for 50g, while Brookfield costs USD 136.80 for 200g. Per gram, Ashford is cheaper, and its expansion stretches each gram further. Budget-conscious tubers who don't mind reordering often should pick Ashford; those who prefer fewer restocks and a fuller flavor should pick Brookfield.
- Tubing machine compatibility: Both work in tubing machines, but Ashford's expanded fill may require a lighter pack, while Brookfield's denser blend feeds more consistently. Brookfield is also suitable for hand rolling. If you hand roll occasionally, Brookfield gives you more flexibility; if you only tube, either works with minor adjustments.
Product facts at a glance
- Ashford Virginia Tubing Tobacco - 50g Can: Ashford Virginia tobacco is expanded using a rapid heating and dry-ice cooling process that visibly increases its volume. This expansion means a 50g can yields more cigarette fill, making it a budget-friendly choice for high-volume tubers.

Ashford Virginia Tubing Tobacco - 50g Can - Brookfield American Blend Cigarette Tubing Tobacco - 200g Tub: Brookfield American Blend is a mild-to-medium American cigarette tobacco that can be used in a tubing machine or hand rolled. Its versatility suits tubers who sometimes switch to hand rolling, and the creamy profile appeals to those who want a smoother smoke.

Brookfield American Blend Cigarette Tubing Tobacco - 200g Tub
Which one should you choose?
Best for
- Cost-conscious tubers who want more cigarettes per gram
- Those who prefer a lighter, pure Virginia taste
- Tubers who make small batches and don't mind reordering
Not for
- Smokers who want a richer, creamy American blend flavor
- Tubers who want the convenience of a large 200g tub
- Hand rollers who want a tobacco that works well for both methods



